Private Family Trust for Estate Planning in Kolkata: Specific vs Discretionary Trusts, Tax, Stamp Duty and Registration
A private family trust is a legal arrangement under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, in which a settlor transfers assets to trustees to hold for named family beneficiaries. Kolkata families use trusts to keep a house or business shares together across generations, provide for a dependent child, protect assets from disputes, and avoid the delay of succession after a death. A trust whose beneficiaries and their shares are fixed (a specific trust) is generally taxed at the beneficiaries’ rates, while a discretionary trust is generally taxed at the maximum marginal rate. Contributions to a trust created solely for relatives are not taxed as gifts. A trust holding immovable property must be created by a registered instrument.
How a private trust works
| Role | Who |
|---|---|
| Settlor | The person who creates the trust and transfers assets |
| Trustees | People (or a company) who hold and manage the assets under the trust deed |
| Beneficiaries | Family members who benefit; can include future generations |
| Trust deed | Sets the purpose, powers, distribution rules and how trustees are replaced |
Revocable or irrevocable?
- Revocable trust: the settlor can take the assets back. Income is taxed in the settlor’s hands, and protection from disputes is limited.
- Irrevocable trust: the settlor cannot take back the assets. Used for genuine estate planning.
Specific vs discretionary trusts: tax
| Type | Beneficiaries and shares | Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Specific (determinate) trust | Named, with fixed shares | Income taxed at the rates applicable to each beneficiary, through the trustee as representative |
| Discretionary trust | Trustees decide who gets what | Generally taxed at the maximum marginal rate, with limited exceptions |
| Trust with business income | Any | Generally taxed at the maximum marginal rate, with exceptions for certain will-created trusts |
Distributions from a trust to beneficiaries of already-taxed income are not taxed again.
Contributions and gifts
Assets transferred to a trust created solely for the benefit of relatives of the settlor are not taxed as gifts in the trust’s hands. Capital gains do not arise on an irrevocable transfer to a trust by way of gift. Stamp duty on the trust deed and on any immovable property transferred applies as per the West Bengal stamp schedule.
Registration
A trust involving immovable property must be created by a registered instrument. Trusts of movable property can be created by a written deed or declaration, but registration is still advisable. The trust gets its own PAN and bank account, and files returns.
Choosing trustees
- At least two trustees, often a family elder and a professional or younger family member.
- A mechanism for replacing trustees on death, incapacity or resignation.
- Clear powers on investment, sale of property and distributions.
NRI beneficiaries
Trusts can have NRI beneficiaries. Distributions to them must follow FEMA rules, and Indian income of the trust remains taxable in India. Beneficiaries abroad may have reporting obligations in their country.
When a trust is not worth it
- When assets are modest and a well-drafted will is enough.
- When the family cannot agree on trustees.
- When the cost of stamp duty on transferring properties is high and the benefits are limited.
Example: a trust for a Kolkata family house
A couple in Ballygunge owns a large house and a portfolio of shares. Their concern is that after them, their three children may quarrel over the house, and one child has special needs. They settle an irrevocable specific trust with the house and part of the portfolio, naming the three children as beneficiaries with fixed shares, the special-needs child receiving a larger share of income for life. Two children and a family lawyer are trustees. The trust deed bars sale of the house for 15 years except by unanimous decision. The remaining assets pass by their wills.
Trust deed: key clauses
- Name, settlor, trustees and beneficiaries.
- Trust property and how more can be added.
- Objects and distribution rules (fixed shares or discretion).
- Trustees’ powers: investment, sale, borrowing, appointing advisers.
- Appointment, removal and replacement of trustees.
- Accounts, audit and reporting to beneficiaries.
- Duration and winding up.
Ongoing compliance
The trust needs PAN, a bank account, books of account, and annual income tax returns. Trustees must keep beneficiaries informed and act in their interest. Where properties are held, the trust pays municipal taxes and handles tenancies. Review the trust every few years with the family.
Trust and stamp duty planning
Transferring property to a trust attracts stamp duty, so families often settle a small corpus first and transfer assets by will to the trust later, or have the trust buy new assets. Plan this sequence with your adviser, as it affects cost and tax.
FAQs
Is a private trust taxed in India?
Yes. A specific trust is generally taxed at beneficiaries’ rates; a discretionary trust generally at the maximum marginal rate.
Is transferring property to a family trust taxable?
Not as a gift if the trust is solely for relatives, but stamp duty applies on immovable property.
Must a family trust be registered?
Yes, if it involves immovable property.
Can a trust be created by a will?
Yes. A testamentary trust comes into existence on the testator’s death under the will.
Can the settlor also be a trustee?
Yes, but for an irrevocable trust meant for estate planning, include independent trustees and avoid retaining control that makes it revocable in substance.
TAXAJ, with its legal team, designs and registers private family trusts and handles their tax compliance in Kolkata. Talk to our Kolkata team.
Last updated 11 November 2026. Sources: Indian Trusts Act, 1882, sections 3, 5, 6 and 73 to 77; Registration Act, 1908; Income-tax law on representative assessees, specific and discretionary trusts, revocable transfers and gifts to trusts for relatives; Indian Stamp Act as applicable in West Bengal. General information only.
